Best Golf Putters Under $200

Two hundred dollars will not buy a CNC conversation piece. It will buy a current blade or mallet with a published stroke type. A research-based look at Cleveland HB SOFT 2 and a sale PING Anser, with prices as of Nov 20, 2026.

Share

Golf Deal Hunter may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

This is a research-based buying guide. The notes below come from published manufacturer and retailer specs, official product pages, and widely reported product details. We have not hands-on tested these products, and we are not inventing review scores or quotes.

Two hundred dollars will not buy you a CNC-milled conversation piece. It will buy you a current blade or mallet with a published stroke type, a face story, and enough left over for a sleeve of balls you will still three-putt with. That is a more honest trade than most putter marketing.

Every model below is listed at or under ~$200 as of Nov 20, 2026. This is not a roll test and not a ranking of inserts. For mid-range and zero-torque options, see our 2026 putter guide.

Approximate prices as of Nov 20, 2026, and marked with a tilde (~). Some figures are sale prices that can end. Re-check the retailer page before you buy.

Quick picks

PutterPublished styleApprox. priceWhere we checked
Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #1Classic blade, plumber's neck, moderate toe hang, slight-arc stroke~$159.99Cleveland / Dunlop Sports US
Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #15Full mallet, single-bend hosel, face-balanced, straight-stroke build~$159.99Cleveland / Dunlop Sports US
PING Scottsdale AnserClassic Anser-style blade, on sale with other Scottsdale models~$198.98 (sale; was $259.99)PGA TOUR Superstore

PGA TOUR Superstore also listed the HB SOFT 2 #1 and #15 at ~$159.99 as of Nov 20, 2026. Official Cleveland pages showed an estimated ship date of Nov 27, 2026, when we checked.

What you can still get under $200

You can get a blade or a mallet, a published stroke type, and a current face design. You generally cannot get a 2026 Odyssey Ai-DUAL insert or a lie-angle-balanced L.A.B. head in this budget; those start at ~$249.99 and ~$399 in our main putter guide. The decision that still matters is the same one at every price: match the head to the stroke, then confirm length.

Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #1

The HB SOFT 2 #1 is Cleveland's most traditional shape in the line: a classic blade with a plumber's neck, moderate toe hang, one-line alignment, and a pistol grip, “best suited for a slight arc stroke.” The official spec table lists a 355-gram head, 34- or 35-inch stock lengths, a 70° lie, and 3° of loft, in right and left hand. Like the rest of the HB SOFT 2 family, it uses Speed Optimized Face Technology — a groove-milling pattern Cleveland says is meant to normalize ball speed across a larger striking area — and a 20-gram counterweight in shafts 35 inches and over.

Official price: ~$159.99 as of Nov 20, 2026. Superstore listed the same model at the same ~$159.99. The official page showed an estimated ship date of Nov 27, 2026, when we checked, so confirm lead time if you need it this week.

Pros (from published specs)

  • A clearly labeled slight-arc blade, in left or right hand, at the lowest verified price here
  • The same official $159.99 as the mallet, so the shape is a choice, not a price jump

Cons (from published specs)

  • A blade is usually less stable on mishits than a larger mallet, on paper
  • Official lead times may not be instant; Superstore may be the faster cart

Check price — Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #1 via Cleveland / Dunlop Sports US

Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #15

The HB SOFT 2 #15 is one of three full-mallet shapes in the family. The official page describes a unique, angular design with a single-bend hosel and a three-line alignment system, “best suited for a straight stroke.” The spec table lists a face-balanced head, 365 grams, an oversize pistol grip, 34- or 35-inch stock lengths, a 70° lie, and 3° of loft, in right hand. The same SOFT face story and 35-inch counterweight apply.

Official price is the same ~$159.99, and Superstore listed it at ~$159.99 as well. If your stroke is closer to straight-back-and-through, or you simply aim a mallet better, this is the shape to look at first — at the same money as the blade. Right-hand only, on the official table we checked.

Pros (from published specs)

  • A face-balanced full mallet, with three-line alignment, at $159.99
  • You can compare it to the #1 blade without changing budgets

Cons (from published specs)

  • Right-hand only on the official spec table
  • It is not a zero-torque design; if that is the feature you want, you are shopping above $200

Check price — Cleveland HB SOFT 2 #15 via Cleveland / Dunlop Sports US

PING Scottsdale Anser

The Scottsdale Anser is the sale PING blade from our main putter guide, and it still squeezes under this cap. Superstore's product page describes the winningest putter shape, heel-toe weighting, a back cavity with a single alignment line, and a lightweight PEBAX face insert used to increase MOI and keep a softer feel. The standard grip is a SuperStroke Tour 2.0 PT Blue pistol.

Street price at PGA TOUR Superstore as of Nov 20, 2026: ~$198.98, down from $259.99. Other Scottsdale models — Superstore has grouped the Anser, Anser 2D, Craz-E, and others at the same sale price — are worth a look if you want a mallet in the same family. A blade and a mallet at $198.98 are still different tools. Confirm length and hosel on the product page before you check out.

Pros (from published specs)

  • A familiar Anser shape, on a clear markdown from $259.99, just under $200
  • Other Scottsdale heads are on the same Superstore sale if you prefer a different shape

Cons (from published specs)

  • About $40 more than the HB SOFT 2 models
  • You still need to match blade versus mallet to your stroke, even at a sale price

Check price — PING Scottsdale Anser via PGA TOUR Superstore

How a weekend golfer might choose

If you want a slight-arc blade at the lowest verified price, start with the HB SOFT 2 #1. If you want a face-balanced mallet at that same price, start with the #15. If you want a PING Anser and can spend the last $40 of the budget, the Scottsdale sale is the one we already used in the 2026 guide. Length still matters more than the last $40. Roll both shapes before you pick a camp.

Who should skip this

Skip a new sub-$200 putter if the one you have is a reasonable length and the miss is a peek, not a head shape. Skip this budget if what you actually want is a 2026 Odyssey insert or a L.A.B. DF3; those live in our 2026 putter guide, above this cap. And skip buying a blade only because it looks like “a real putter.”

FAQ

Is a $160 putter “good enough”?

It can be, if the length and stroke type are right. Cleveland is selling a stroke-specific hosel, alignment, and grip at this price, and PING is selling a classic Anser on sale just under $200. We will not invent a roll winner against a $300 mallet.

Blade or mallet under $200?

The same starting point as at any price: blade and some toe hang for a more arcing stroke, mallet and face balance for a straighter stroke. It is a starting point, not a law. The #1 and the #15 let you make that choice at the same $159.99.

Should I buy from the official site or Superstore?

The HB SOFT 2 price was ~$159.99 in both places when we checked. Official pages showed a later estimated ship date; Superstore may be faster if the head is in stock. Re-check shipping before you decide.

What length should I buy?

Stock HB SOFT 2 and many Scottsdale listings start at 34 or 35 inches. Standard is not the same as correct. If you are crouched over a 35 or standing tall over a 34, get the length checked.